Thursday, November 02, 2017



Maybe I heard it on TV.

Maybe someone who seemed to know what he or she was talking about told me and I believed it.

Maybe it came to me in a dream.

I don't know where I got this idea, but somewhere I heard that Frank Sinatra -- yes Frank Sinatra, dammit -- once said that the saddest song he ever heard was a strange old American song from 1895 called "The Band Played On."

Even with the magic of Google I can't verify if this is true. I can't even find any Sinatra covers of the song.

And damn, I want to believe it!

Most of the versions of this tune -- with lyrics by John F. Palmer and music by Charles B. Ward -- don't play it for the sadness. Often it's played for laughs.

But when you think about it -- it's there. While Palmer's lyrics allude to love and good times, there is tension just under the surface. Disaster is just around the corner.

The song is about this guy named Casey who's on the dance floor with a "strawberry blonde" -- "the girl he adored."

But things aren't going well for poor Casey. He's whacked out of his mind on booze or who knows what.

... his brain was so loaded it nearly exploded;
The poor girl would shake with alarm.

He loves this woman but he's not sure what to do and he's only succeeding in terrifying her. But Casey is determined.

He'd ne'er leave the girl with the strawberry curls
And the band played on.

Maybe she can escape his clutches after he falls on his face. Or maybe they're married and there's no way out for her

But it's obvious there will be no happy ending here for Casey or the blonde.

Of course I'm just talking about the chorus of the song. Most folks in the modern era who know the song are not familiar with the verses. But as far as I'm concerned, that's just as well. The song's power is in the image of Casey about to spin out of control as his partner hangs on, trying not to panic.

One of the first, if not the first, to record "The Band Played On" -- in 1895 -- was a singer named Dan W. Quinn (1859-1939), promoted in his day as "The King of Comic Singers" (though he could also be known as "The King of Racist Singers.")

Here's a 1941 version by a group called The Jesters

You know if the Hoosier Hot Shots covered something I'm writing about, I'm going to include it. Are you ready, Hezzie?

Here's a swinging hepcat version by a guy named Frank D'Rone

And this is a fairly recent one by Richard Thompson from a 2013 compilation of "turn-of-the-century" songs called The Beautiful Old. I love Thompson and I love this version, even though he tacks on a sappy ending, undercutting the beautiful terror of Casey's drunken waltz.

Update 11-7-17: 

Sean at KSFR did some fancy Googlin' and found a Frank Sinatra fan forum that shows Ol' Blues was at least familiar with this song and apparently had performed it a couple of times.

A guy named Larry posted in 2007:

Back in the 70s I caught Frank Sinatra several times at the Westchester Premier Theater. In one show he stunned the audience by turning down the lights except for maybe a single spot light, sat on a stool, and sang the oldie "Casey Would Waltz With the Strawberry Blond". Very little, if any, accompaniment as I recall. It is one of the memories I've treasured through the years. He may have sung another song along with it but I don't remember what it was.

Another guy, Bob, responded:

Larry, it may interest you to know that Sinatra FIRST sang "The Band Played On" in a Songs By Sinatra (Old Gold Cigarettes) CBS radio show, as part of a medley with solo piano accompaniment by André Previn, September 25, 1946.

The Westchester Premier Theater performance which you mention (second show of the day) occurred 30 years later TO THE DAY, on September 25, 1976, with Bill Miller doing the solo piano honors.

Those are the ONLY two documented performances of this song by FS.

Unfortunately, in a later post Bob says there is no known recording of this radio show.

I did a little Googling myself and found a mention of the 1946 radio set on a German site.

September 25, 1946 Songs By Sinatra (CBS)
Sponsor: Old Gold Cigarettes
Ansager: Marvin Miller
Orchesterleitung: Axel Stordahl 
Künstler: Frank Sinatra, The Pied Pipers
Gäste: Sandra Gould

1. Night And Day
2. Blue Skies
3. And The Band Played On 
4. I Wonder What's Become Of Sally
5. After The Ball
6. I Wonder Who Kissing Her Now
7. On The Boardwalk In Atlantic City
8. The Things We Did Last Summer
9. September Song
10. Put Your Dreams Away

For more deep dives into songs, check out The Stephen W. Terrell Web Log Songbook


  1. I'm wondering about Sinatra's perceiving the song as sad. Why was Casey's brain "so loaded" and loaded with what? Is he inebriated and scaring the strawberry blonde? Is his brain loaded with lust for the strawberry blonde, which she perceives and is frightened by? So many questions, but no answers. I've Googled, but found no explanations. Perhaps Sinatra knew the answer. Thus, his comment on it being a deeply sad song. I understand "and the band played on" being sad in the context of the Titanic, for example, but it is difficult to understand why it would be considered sad if either drunkenness or lust were loading Casey's brain. Mysteries drive me mad. Thanks for the post. My mom sang this song to me as a child, so it's part of the soundtrack of my life.

    1. Thanks, Robin. I don't know exactly when you left tis comment but I'm only seeing it now, April 2023.

      I believe the clue to the "sadness" is the line "the poor girl would quake with alarm." Casey wants the girl, but he's so loaded he's only scaring her.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.


  Sunday, April 21, 2024 KSFR, Santa Fe, NM, 101.1 FM  Webcasting! 10 p.m. to midnight Sundays Mountain Time Host: Steve Terrell E...